Tuesday, March 3, 2009

SLoodle Workshop

On Monday, March 2, 2009, I attended a Social Presence in Virtual Worlds (SLrl) workshop on SLoodle. This workshop was hosted in-world by Josmas Flores at Insula Docta TCD (slurl http://tinyurl.com/ddnypn). The workshop took place in a wonderful auditorium as shown below.

Auditorium on Insula Docta TCD (photo taken March 2/09)

Sloodle (Simulation Linked Object Oriented Dynamic Learning Environment) is a 3D online education system for SL that integrates with Moodle, an open-source CMS. The workshop presented some of the features of SLoodle including a Registration booth, Choice tool, Web-intercom and SLoodle HUD.

Since I am a Moodle user, I was very excited to see how the CMS interacted with SL. It must first be understood that we were in-world accessing the tools to interact with Moodle. To begin we had to register into the Moodle course by clicking on the SLoodle registration booth (left-booth shown in image below). This opened a new browser window to the registration page of the Moodle site it was connected to.
SLoodle Registration (left) and Enrolment (right) booths (photo taken March 2/09)

After completing the registration, through a confirmation email, I was able to enol into the course by clicking the enrolment booth (right-booth shown in image above). Viewable through my web-browser, this took me to the course located in Moodle. The purpose of registering and enroling from the in-world location was so that the connection could be made between SL and Moodle for the two to begin communicating.

Once registered and enroled into the Moodle course we were able to try some of the tools integrating the CMS with SL. The first one we looked at was the Choice tool which allows students to vote and see the results in either SL or Moodle. For example, we were asked to vote on what type of pizza we like with some participants voting in-world and others voting in the Moodle course. Participants were able to view the choice results from either the SL or Moodle environment.

The second tool we tried was the Web-intercom. A chat-room that brings a Moodle chat-room and SL chats together. When participants in SL text through local chat and Moodle participants text through the connected Moodle chat room, both groups can see the text chat.

The third tool we saw was the SLoodle HUD (Multi-function SLoodle Toolbar). This tool is described as enhancing the SL user-interface. When wearing the SLoodle HUD we were able to use a selection of classroom gestures, see a list of the Moodle user names from participating avatars or write entries directly into our Moodle blogs from SL.

One question individuals may have is...why do we want a virtual world, such as SL, to communicate with a CMS like Moodle? When we begin to look at some the items limiting access to SL we quickly see factors like high-end computer requirements and complicated interface emerge. By connecting SL with Moodle we allow lower-end computers and individuals who find the SL interface confusing to communicate with in-world participants through the Moodle environment.

Sunday, March 1, 2009

Further Analysis of Parcel Data Collection

The ECMM parcel will require tools to collect data that will be analyzed for both development and research purposes. Two of the tools I am considering to use in collecting statistics for the parcel are offered by Maya Realities and RabbitStats. The following information will describe each of the tools and provide details as to which proximity sensor was chosen for the ECMM parcel.

Maya Realities is a service company in SL, who began business in April 2007, focusing on analytics. For an Introduction to their services view the following slidecast.

Maya Realities offers a basic proximity sensor, among other more advanced solutions, for $L1 that collects basic land parcel information including number of unique avatars visiting, total time spent on a land parcel, and average time spent per avatar. To purchase a proximity sensor or find out more about their services visit their in-world office at
http://slurl.com/secondlife/Jingbo/67/35/30/

RabbitStats provides statistics on the following details of an SL property:
  • Identify and record names of visiting residents
  • Record length of time visitors spend on property
  • Record multiple visits
  • Stats provided through graphs and charts
  • Provides daily email listing property visitors
  • Premium account provides information to be downloaded as CSV file.
RabbitStats can be accessed from their in-world store located at http://slurl.com/secondlife/Tehama/104/203/24?title=Rabbit%20Glen. Pricing is separated into three account types:
  1. Basic - free
  2. Premium - L$5 per collector per day
  3. Non-Profit/Educational - free
After reviewing the information on each of the proximity sensors provided by both Maya Realities and RabbitStats, I was unsure as to which one to use. I therefore decided to try them both and come to a conclusion based on experience with both products. I will use the free options from both products to determine if one outperforms the other. Stay tuned for results...

Update... (March 8, 2009)
When looking for the proximity sensors from both Maya Realities and RabbitStats, I was only able to find the one from RabbitStats in-world. After looking around the Maya Realities in-world office, I was unable to locate any of the free versions of the sensor. I probably could have found out more information if I would have left a message at the Maya Realities' in-world office. The proximity sensor from RabbitStats was much easier to get in-world. I went to the SLURL for RabbitStats, mentioned above, and there was a free copy of the proximity sensor to take.

Free copy of RabbitStats proximity sensor (photo taken March 1, 2009)

The instructions, provided with the free version of the RabbitStats proximity sensor, made the setup process quite easy. Setup instructions direct you to the RabbitStats.com website to setup a new account. After the account is setup you enter in the code of your specific proximity sensor and it begins collecting data. The script of your specific sensor is placed into the contents folder of an object in the area in which you want to collect data. You can set the distance in which the proximity sensor collects data. You can then go to the domain name of your RabbitStats account to edit sensor setting, add more sensors, view data, and add more users to access the account. When the sensor is up and running it can be set to email reports to identified members.

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Final Session - Evaluating a Presence in SL

The final session of the in-world, non-credit course, "Setting up an Educational Presence in SL" focused on evaluating your presence in SL. We looked at ways to assess the success of efforts in creating an educational presence in SL. This session was led by Maxito Ricardo (SL) Tom Peters (RL) who we quickly realized is an expert in evaluation and proximity sensor data collection.

The session began at the open air auditorium on Info Island (http://slurl.com/secondlife/Info%20Island/116/126/33) with a discussion on how to evaluate an institution's presence-building efforts in-world. Maxito started the discussion by explaining that many educational institutions, "are testing the waters to see if SL is another good way to pursue their overall mission...teaching, research service, etc.". Currently Maxito perceives institutions to be constructing spaces in SL. These virtual spaces are being used to hold events such as classes, lectures, symposia, social events and handle resources (create, collect, organize and distribute). He believes institutions hope their students (avatars) feel like they are part of the campus environment by trying to "recreate that campus feel." One of the benefits of the SL build space, Maxito explained, "it's much easier and cheaper in SL to build and reconfigure the built space to meet changing needs."

It was expressed that there is something about 3D virtual spaces that are very attractive to humans, however it takes collective efforts and time to understand new technologies. An interesting example of this was the development of the U of S interstate highway system. It was originally sold to officials as an instrument of national security. Troops needed to be able to move quickly in the event of a Soviet invasion. The interstate was not foreseen to assist in changing the entire urban landscape, creating a southwest population drift and changing the way people eat. With these types of unknown outcomes, Maxito believes, "one of the august responsibilities of any institution becoming active in SL is that they almost need to think about everything, from soup to nuts." Therefore when beginning to assess institutional presence-building in SL it is important to understand the focus of the effort. Is it to explore new ways of teaching and learning? Alternative ways to deliver distributed and distance education? Can it be used to attract prospective students or connect with alumni?

When it comes to assessment there are many things, in SL, that could be evaluated including buildings, grounds, teaching and learning tools, services, events, etc.. Maxito expressed, "I think that assessment here could be more important and useful than assessment in the real world." This is partly due to the fact that it is easier to make changes in SL but also, he believes, "the power to improve is much deeper in SL than in the real world." The ability to have decision-making power and implement change is a strong motivator for many individuals in SL. In RL there may be many factors (laws, bureaucracy, cost, etc.) that prevent an individual from being able to quickly implement desired change to their enviroment. Maxito believes this to be an advantage in SL, "Lots of people can move buildings on this island, for instance. Not many people have the decision-making power, technology, etc. in the real world to do that."

Three distinctions, Maxito mentioned, from real world assessment that may be useful in SL are provided by the 3-U's:
  1. Usability
  2. Use
  3. Usefulness
When we begin to look at the architecture in SL there are some wonderfully constructed objects. We see beautiful high-rise buidings, sky classrooms and underwater creations among other works of art. However, Maxito has used data, from proximity sensors, to research the use of space in SL and has generally found open air spaces and ground level floors of buildings receive the most traffic. Many of the unique spaces that are out of the way do not see much traffic. This may be something to consider when planning an SL build...if you want high traffic, build an open air space however, if you want private space where your group will not be interrupted, build it in an out of the way location.

Maxito identified further distinctions to be valid in SL between behaviour, attitudes and opinions. When evaluating behaviour we may look at where avatars go, what they do, what they touch and use. In evaluating attitudes and opinions we can begin to look into avatar's beliefs, what they are saying and how they may be feeling.

The group was presented with some evaluation methodologies currently being used in SL. Many of the methodologies used in RL to analyze and collect research data are currently being used in SL including surveys, focus groups and interviews.

Surveys in SL are a useful, convenient method to collect research data. However, as in RL, it is difficult to get individuals to complete surveys and in some instances the responses may be heavily weighted towards specific sub-groups . One of the benefits in creating surveys in SL is the creativity that can be designed into the survey. In a virtual world surveys can look much different than in RL. For example on Health InfoIsland, a survey was designed as a series of avatar-sized panels.

Focus groups and individual interviews can also be conducted in SL. Maxito believes these data collection methods work well because, "People tend to be very open and thoughtful here in SL."

A tool, in SL, that may be used to collect behvioural data on a parcel of land is a "proximity sensor." These tools allow 24/7 monitoring and analysis of raw traffic counts, avatar names, time spent in specific locations, objects touched, etc.. A couple of companies offering these products can be located at rabbitstats.com and www.mayarealities.com.

We teleported to Karuna, a grant funded island dedicated to AIDS awareness, to see some examples of proximity sensors. The sensors we saw were distributed around the island to assist in collecting data to evaluate their presence building efforts. Although the sensors are deployed around the island, the controls are placed in one location so the data can easily be harvested.

Proximity Sensor control cones (photo taken February 22/09)

The sensors used on Karuna Island are from Thomas Conover Products. Basic sensors are free of charge but ones more advanced can be purchased. Maxito explained that he finds these sensors easy to deploy, manage and harvest. Another aspect he found beneficial about these sensors is they can be set up so they don't cross parcel lines. If a sensor is placed near a location in a corner of a land parcel, it can be setup not to report on activity on the adjoining parcels. The reports produced for these specific sensors provided stats on number of avatars and how long they stayed on average.